
An Eye For an Eye
Episode 1 • Mar 04, 2016
Sarah finds herself at the center of a series of copycat killings and visits the man who murdered her parents in prison and he imparts a cryptic message.
Thirty years ago, in the sleepy community of Waterbury, a killer known as “The Executioner” murdered Sarah Bennett's parents. Now Sarah and her husband Dylan have returned to town, only to find herself the centerpiece in a series of horrifying murders centered around the seven deadly sins.
40 episodes total
Status
Ended
First Aired
2016
Rating
6.7/10
327 votes • HD
People
Basil Garvey
Detective Kenneth Rijkers
Georges Rondeau
Regina Simcoe
Viviana Botticelli
Andrew May Jr.
Venetia Botticelli
Verdi Botticelli
Margaret Mehar
Dr. Melanda Israel
Episodes
Episode 1 • Mar 04, 2016
Sarah finds herself at the center of a series of copycat killings and visits the man who murdered her parents in prison and he imparts a cryptic message.
Episode 2 • Mar 04, 2016
Sarah receives a gruesome package at her new gallery. The Executioner exacts justice on citizens of Waterbury. Sarah attempts to decipher a message in her parcel. Sarah's grandmother pleads with her to leave town.
Episode 3 • Mar 11, 2016
A disturbing secret from Sarah's past confirms her belief that the police have arrested the wrong person for the murders.
Episode 4 • Mar 18, 2016
Sarah believes the killer is using the seven deadly sins as part of their plan and is disappointed by the police chief's lack of responsiveness. Unfortunately Sarah's attempt to investigate the murders leads to misfortune.
Episode 5 • Mar 25, 2016
Sarah blames herself when another disturbing murder occurs. Meanwhile Allison has mixed reactions to Dylan's TV commentaries about the killings.
Episode 6 • Apr 01, 2016
Sarah learns of some unsettling information about her past from Tom Winston, which leads her to believe she knows the next target of the Executioner.
Episode 1 • Oct 17, 2017
Five years after concealing a murder, guilt-stricken summer camp counselors return in midwinter to the scene of their crime, now a utopian commune.
Episode 2 • Oct 17, 2017
After a body is found and a guest vanishes, both groups discover they're trapped at the camp with communication to the outside world cut off.
Episode 3 • Oct 17, 2017
As the list of victims continues to grow, the number of possible suspects narrows and the two groups are forced to cooperate despite mutual suspicion.
Episode 4 • Oct 17, 2017
The histories of several characters unfold in flashback, revealing surprising connections, while an innocent hiker is pulled into the unfolding drama.
Episode 5 • Oct 17, 2017
The gruesome past and false identity of a commune member is discovered, although it may be too late to save the fellow camper they have kidnapped.
Episode 6 • Oct 17, 2017
Desperate to discover the identity of the killer preying on them, the remaining survivors reluctantly conduct a mock hearing to learn the truth.
Episode 1 • May 23, 2019
On the first anniversary of a mysterious slaying, the masked killer responsible strikes again, butchering one of the earlier crime's eyewitnesses.
Episode 2 • May 23, 2019
Connections to Kit are revealed in flashbacks, while a couple's secret affair is exposed via social media and another slaying strikes the community.
Episode 3 • May 23, 2019
As school is dismissed for the summer, more shocking memories from the past year surface and a teacher who tries to be an ally to Saadia pays a price.
Episode 4 • May 23, 2019
The Druid kills again as Amy recalls her role in Kit's death, Roberta questions multiple witnesses, and plans get underway for the solstice party.
Episode 5 • May 23, 2019
Roberta and Pujit identify a suspect while Violet's lurid, exploitative murder blog goes too far, making her and Joe targets of outrage and revenge.
Episode 6 • May 23, 2019
Attendees of the solstice party are stalked by the Druid while someone engineers a violent confrontation in the basement between Angel and Dan.
Episode 1 • Aug 12, 2021
As the various members of the Galloway family gather to depart for their annual reunion, years-long tensions and rivalries flare up, as they arrive at the private island home of patriarch Spencer. After receiving shocking news about his end-of-life plans, the group is faced with the resumption of a long-dormant round of cruel family competitions from the past.
Episode 2 • Aug 12, 2021
Shocking revelations make the Galloway family competition even more difficult, as grizzly discoveries and panic grip the family, and the killer claims the first victims. Meanwhile, suspicions start to mount against one outsider following an unexpected reveal.
Episode 3 • Aug 19, 2021
Reeling from witnessing a gruesome murder, the remaining Galloway family regroup to try and escape the island. But they quickly realize the competition can’t be stopped, no matter what. Seamus and Christy’s marriage tensions drive them further apart as more secrets from the past are revealed.
Episode 4 • Aug 26, 2021
Paranoia and suspicion grow among the surviving group, as another body is discovered and terrible secrets from the past come to the surface.
Episode 5 • Sep 02, 2021
Still reeling from Birgit’s confession, Vincent takes his anger out on a panicked Liv, who searches for her missing mother with Theo. With Florence still focused on Vincent, O’Keefe looks for maternal comfort from Grace. The next contest for the family brings new allegiances and stunning betrayals, as Florence makes a horrific sacrifice to save her own skin.
Episode 6 • Sep 09, 2021
After discovering Florence’s selfish crime, Theo takes matters into his own hands in dealing with his wicked mother. Christy learns more about Aphra’s past, with grisly results.
Episode 1 • Apr 06, 2023
The city's elite are thrown into panic when a member of the upper crust is murdered by a killer dubbed "the Widow." Detective Rijkers is put on the case. The city's most powerful man, Basil Garvey, is a target and works to control the investigation.
Episode 2 • Apr 06, 2023
The Widow strikes again, and Kenneth Rijkers begins connecting the killings to a 12-year-old mystery, while Basil Garvey, a business oligarch, pulls a number of strings to control the investigation.
Episode 3 • Apr 13, 2023
Enid's newspaper declares another Widow murder; panic rises, and Kashtinsky gets high to keep focused; Eddie tries to flee, but Basil reminds him that he owns him; Kenneth uncovers proof that links the victims to the killing of Margaret Mehar.
Episode 4 • Apr 20, 2023
The Widow sends a nasty treat to Basil and friends, which sends Kashtinsky over the edge; the Botticelli sisters arrange for Verdi to have their portraits taken; Georges Rondeau, the prime suspect in the murders, preys on Regina.
Episode 5 • Apr 27, 2023
The Widow's latest victim is found on Valentine's Day, dragged to death behind a horse and made up to look like Cupid; a torn piece of the Widow's weeds sends Kenneth and Regina off on a hunt; Salomé entertains bidders for Verdi.
Episode 6 • May 04, 2023
The pressure gets to Israel, who admits to her and seven other involvements in Margaret's death; Kenneth secures the suspects, freeing only Israel to operate on a friend of Regina's - inadvertently putting her into the Widow's clutches.
Recommendations
2021 • TV Show
2005 • TV Show
2020 • TV Show
2025 • TV Show
1969 • TV Show
2021 • TV Show
2022 • TV Show
2024 • TV Show
2017 • TV Show
1952 • TV Show
2011 • TV Show
2018 • TV Show